Katharine McPhee – I Fall in Love Too Easily (Album Review)

One-time American Idol runner-up Katharine McPhee has spent over a decade building off her success on the hit television show. After taking second place in Season Five, McPhee released a self-titled Pop album in January 2007. The record debuted at number two on the Billboard album chart, selling 116,000 copies in its first week, falling only behind Norah Jones’ Not Too Late. After unfortunately being let go from RCA Records in 2008, she released her follow-up, Unbroken, to mixed reviews in 2010. Her third album, a holiday collection, titled Christmas Is the Time to Say I Love You, released just in time for the 2010 Holiday season, ranked 11th best on Billboard’s Top Holiday Albums. She would go on to release her fourth studio offering, 2015’s Hysteria, independently, then seemingly turn her focus elsewhere.

During the intervening years, McPhee has had some success on-screen, appearing in seven films since 2007, had a recurring role on the NBC Musical/Drama series Smash, and, since 2014, has been one of the lead actors on CBS Action-Drama Scorpion. Now returning to music, McPhee’s fifth album, I Fall in Love Too Easily, out November 17, 2017 on BMG Music, is a collection of Jazz standards performed in a classic, lounge-act style. Whether this formula will turn out to be the one that sees McPhee realize her dream of musical stardom remains to be seen, but the collection of tracks that she has put together do a good job of showcasing her vocals.

The album opens with the oft-covered “All the Way,” made famous by Frank Sinatra. McPhee’s interpretation is fairly straightforward: her voice is strong and she gives a breathy, almost soulful performance that is passable. “I’ll Be Seeing You,” also performed by Sinatra – along with a legion of other acts over the decades – comes next, and McPhee’s version, while containing all the elements of previous versions – the strings, somber piano, and even some vocal flourishes – misses the mark somehow.

McPhee runs through eight more tracks on the album – each sounding like their forebears, with twinkling piano, mild orchestration, and the usual easy-listening hallmarks – but in McPhee’s hands, they are missing something compelling; the album tries to be intimate and soulful, but there is a hollowness that is inescapable throughout. The songs are not bad, her vocals are solid, but there is something missing to the entire production, and to some listeners, it may become redundant.

Sadly, on what ought to be the highlight of the album, “Who Can I Turn To,” first made popular by Tony Bennett in the 1960s, McPhee reaches the height of lounge act cliché. As with the rest of the album, her vocals are passable, even somewhat playful.

While it is a listenable album and completely inoffensive, I Fall in Love Too Easily is most likely bound for elevators nationwide immediately. While the musical arrangements are perfectly acceptable and McPhee’s vocals are sufficient to the task of singing these songs, her delivery and performance create an album that feels like a practice in going through the motions. Ultimately, that makes this collection of classics somehow forgettable. For these reasons, CrypticRock gives I Fall in Love Too Easily 3 of 5 stars.

Purchase I Fall in Love Too Easily:

[amazon_link asins=’B0765JNPB1,B075ZCQYDD,B075ZHZHX6,B075ZCNWFM,B075ZFBJ9G,B075ZBNG7V,B075ZFTDDK,B075ZF8W6Q,B075ZHM1YX’ template=’ProductCarousel’ store=’crypticrock-20′ marketplace=’US’ link_id=’03ccc404-cf6f-11e7-b1e3-1d2a7266e001′]

Like the in-depth, diverse coverage of Cryptic Rock? Help us in support to keep the magazine going strong for years to come with a small donation.

Allen J. MillerAuthor posts

Avatar for Allen J. Miller


  • Finding the opposite of this review. If you put this record on whether it be in the morning with a cup of coffee or evening with a cup of wine it will entrance you. Especially for the winter season, McPhee’s soft subtle vocals captures both the warm and fuzzy feelings of falling in love mixed with the loneliness and heartache that comes with losing love. The “hollow feeling the reviewer mentioned can easily be interpreted as a haunting emptiness that someone has when they feel like they may never fall in love. The album tells a the story best starting with “All the way expressing the quintessential ideal of love, then taking us through the iterations of falling head over heels and then heartbreak. Ending with “blame it on my youth/ you make me feel so young” represents that duality perfectly as Mcphee sings it playfully but with a kind coolness showing the desire to believe in love but the subtle understanding that that may be a naive ideal to have. It’s romance meets reality which makes it so relatable.

  • What’s missing here? It should be obvious.. How about diction? These songs are not trite little ditties that litter the new world of auto-tuned pop music. These songs have lyrics that need to be understood to have meaning. To anyone who truly loves this album (and not merely a Katharine McPhee fan). I encourage you to listen to the works of women singers like Sarah Vaughan, Ella Fitzgerald, Nancy Wilson, Peggy Lee, Chris Connor, June Christie, Helen Forest, Anita O’Day, Dinah Washington, Ethel Ennis, Dinah Shore, Billie Holiday, Barbara Streisand. Marlene VerPlanck, Diane Reeves, Diana Krall,, Helen Merrill, Judy Garland, etc. If you are allergic to singers over 50, How about Lady Gaga and Canada’s Diana Panton? .All of these singers have recorded superior versions of these kind of songs to Ms McPhee’s effort here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *